Questions · 3 min read

Are makeup testers in stores safe to use?

It depends. Treat shared makeup testers as potentially contaminated, especially if a product or applicator has touched other shoppers' skin. The FDA warns that counter testers are more likely to become contaminated than cosmetics used at home. If you need to compare a shade, use a fresh disposable applicator and avoid shared tools on your eyes or lips.

When it is usually fine

  • A sealed sample or individually supplied disposable applicator is available
  • You can assess a color on a clean card without applying a shared tester to your face

When to replace it

What to do

  1. Ask for an unopened sample or a single-use applicator rather than using a shared wand.
  2. If a disposable swab is provided, use it only once and do not put it back into a shared container.
  3. Avoid applying community testers directly to your eyelids, lash line or lips.
  4. Wash your hands after handling communal products and stop if a product causes irritation.

Why the product at the counter differs from your own

A tester sits in public and may be opened and handled throughout the day. You cannot know whether previous customers washed their hands, replaced an applicator or returned a used wand to the container. The FDA specifically cautions consumers that shared store testers are more susceptible to contamination than the same formulas used by one person at home. The concern is the shared handling, not a claim that every tester carries a dangerous microorganism. A product can also look ordinary while having been handled without hygienic care.

Safer ways to check a shade before buying

First look for shade cards, sealed samples or brand-provided single-use tools. If a store offers a tester that must be applied, avoid putting a communal brush or wand on your face. The FDA suggests using a fresh cotton swab when somebody feels a trial application is necessary. Never return a swab that has touched skin to a communal jar or tube. Clean handling matters for all cosmetics, and it matters particularly for eye-area products. If a store has no hygienic way to sample a product, comparing the package shade or asking about its return policy is preferable to sharing an applicator.

FAQ

Is trying a shared mascara wand on my lashes a good idea?

No. A community wand can transfer material from earlier users. Choose a sealed sample or an unused applicator instead.

Are lipstick testers safer if I wipe the surface first?

Wiping alone does not prove that a shared product is uncontaminated. Prefer individual samples, disposable tools or a shade card.

Can I safely swatch a shade without putting it on my face?

You can reduce direct facial contact by using a color card or an unused single-use tool. That does not establish that an opened communal product is sterile.

This is general guidance compiled from the sources below. It is not medical advice. Always follow your product's label, and stop using anything that irritates your skin or eyes. If you have symptoms that worry you, talk to a doctor or pharmacist.

Sources

  1. Shelf Life and Expiration Dating of Cosmetics, U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Accessed September 24, 2026.
  2. Microbiological Safety and Cosmetics, U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Accessed October 1, 2026.
  3. When to toss your makeup and sunscreen, American Academy of Dermatology. Accessed September 24, 2026.